LS9, Creator of Synthetic Microbes to Make Biofuel, Edges Toward Moment of Truth
Every hot startup has to put up or shut up at some point. This is when it’s time to stop talking about the gee-whiz founding idea and scientific progress. It’s the point when a company needs to prove it can operate a disciplined, sustainable business. The moment is fast approaching for LS9.
LS9, the South San Francisco-based maker of renewable biofuels, has been hot stuff in the cleantech world for a few years. The company counts a trio of star scientific founders in UC Berkeley’s Jay Keasling, Chris Somerville of the Energy Biosciences Institute, and Harvard University’s George Church. It has deep-pocketed venture capitalists on both coasts in Cambridge, MA-based Flagship Ventures and Silicon Valley’s Khosla Ventures and Lightspeed Ventures, who have pumped in $45 million since the company was founded in 2005.
The buzz came from being part of the nascent field of synthetic biology. As Craig Venter has recently demonstrated, scientists are getting better at manipulating the fundamental unit of life, the cell. In the case of LS9, the company has sought to swap in and out a few enzymes inside bacteria so that instead of converting sugars into fatty acids, they could become super-efficient engines for converting sugars into fuels like diesel. Change out an enzyme here or there, and LS9 can also make higher-priced industrial chemicals like the ones that go into soap or toothpaste. The key would be to do this through an industrial fermentation process, and do the work at large scale, at low cost, using existing infrastructure, and in a controlled, reproducible manner.
The first couple of years for LS9, according to R&D chief Stephen del Cardayre, were about proving that the company could in fact create a one-step process in which sugar goes into a fermenter and fuels, rather than fats, come out. If the company could do this in a straight one-step process, without creating chemical intermediaries that need to undergo an expensive hydrogenation refinement process, then they’d have an edge over competitors on cost. The next couple of years were about showing the LS9 process could work in a pilot scale, in 1,000-liter batches. The company checked that box. It even showed the fuel in this tiny quantity could pass ASTM certification, which basically says it meets performance standards and won’t wreck engines.
But this year, LS9 will find out if it’s really ready to go from the lab to the factory. The company bought a mothballed fermentation plant in Okeechobee, Florida—a rural part of the Sunshine State—for a paltry $2 million. The plan is to retrofit this old plant so that it can make the same UltraClean diesel that comes out of the California pilot facility, but in 200,000-gallon reactors. Operating at full tilt, this plant has potential to pump out 10 million gallons of diesel a year. If LS9 can achieve that kind of scale, it would be a critical step toward its goal of lowering the cost from about $100 a barrel of fuel to $50 a barrel.
“We are already competitive today with a $100 barrel of oil. For a young company, we’re pretty happy with that,” del Cardayre says. “We’ve been setting some aggressive milestones and making improvements in the productivity. We are on target to the ultimate target, $50 a barrel, without subsidy.”
The Okeechobee plant isn’t ready to do that work just yet. It needs retrofitting, and won’t be ready to start doing demonstration runs until the end of this year, del Cardayre says. But LS9 expects to be ready to start generating revenue from actual fuel produced in Florida next year.
“The real commercial volumes will come in 2012, 2013,” he says.
If LS9 can get its costs that low, and its volume of oil production that high, then suddenly this isn’t really a story about ideas and synthetic biology anymore. It’s more about a potentially big business, in creating renewable hydrocarbons for fuel, plastics, and industrial chemicals.
Partnerships are key to the LS9 strategy. The company thinks of the renewable fuel business as having four key components—feedstock or biomass material, technology, production, and sales and distribution, according to Greg Pal, LS9’s senior director of business development. The startup plans to find partners to supply feedstock. In the beginning, these will be farmers who grow sugar cane, although the company might switch to cellulosic material like switchgrass over time if it can be obtained more cheaply. “We’re feedstock agnostic,” Pal says.
On the other end of the spectrum, LS9 is finding partners to market and distribute the end products like fuel (Chevron), or consumer chemicals (Procter & Gamble). What LS9 wants to retain, its secret sauce, are the engineered microbes that convert the sugar into fuel—the core technology. And, even though this is an expensive proposition, it also wants to control the production of fuels, del Cardayre says.
He didn’t say how much capital this will take, and how many fermentation plants LS9 wants to build around the country. The idea is still obviously a long, long way from fundamentally disrupting the way transportation works in developed countries. The global market for energy and transportation is worth an estimated $7 trillion. If LS9’s big fermentation plant in Florida can prove that it remains as efficient at large scale as it is now at 1,000 liters—which would be a significant feat of engineering—it will still only provide a tiny portion of the supply for even the state of Florida’s diesel needs.
But that’s the plan, to get into production. LS9’s CEO, Bill Haywood, has loads of experience at oilmaker Tesoro in building up production facilities, getting them started, and running them efficiently. The company isn’t asking anybody to change the car they drive, the station they fill up at, or the fuel they put in their tank. To the consumer, the only major difference is that the fuel comes from a renewable source. There will probably be publicity stunts or displays of political theater, showing renewable fuel in jets or race cars, which can be good for raising money. LS9, like most biofuel companies, is also going to take advantage of government tax breaks and subsidies whenever and wherever it can. But the real proof of whether LS9 will make a difference, R&D chief del Cardayre says, will be when big customer orders start coming in.
“It’s when your big customer says ‘We like your material, and we’ll buy as much of it as you can make,'” del Cardayre says. “That’s when you know.”
Trending on Xconomy
By posting a comment, you agree to our terms and conditions.