Circle’s Bitcoin Service is Free—But Someone’s Gotta Pay

If bitcoin goes mainstream, companies like Circle Internet Financial will probably lead the way.

The Boston-based startup isn’t banking on techno-libertarian visions of a unregulated financial system. Instead, Circle is hoping to bring the emerging digital currency trend to everyday consumers by giving it the familiar feel of online banking, complete with trusted-middleman protections.

The price ain’t bad, either. Circle unveiled its digital wallet service this week with an enticing pitch: convert your real money to bitcoins and send them instantly and securely to other people around the world. Everything’s fully insured. And it’s all completely free.

So how will Circle make money? The company, headed by experienced technology entrepreneur Jeremy Allaire, isn’t giving many specifics right now.

Circle has raised about $26 million from private investors, which should be enough to bankroll its consumer services for quite a while. But eventually, somebody will have to pay to keep it going, and a generation of savvy digital consumers has learned to be suspicious when there’s no clear business model behind a new service.

How do you convince people to start using an obscure, volatile digital currency without a clear idea of how the service will stay in business? Allaire, whose previous entrepreneurial successes include digital video company Brightcove, isn’t blind to this conundrum.

Jeremy Allaire Headshot


“If you go on social media sites like Reddit, there are a lot of users speculating,” he says. But right now, possible business models are “not things that we’re going to talk about, or have really given that much thought to.”

If you poke and prod a little, however, it’s possible to get a broad idea of the business models Circle might try in the future. And, importantly, where it’s not planning on making money.

In an interview, Allaire said Circle was taking general inspiration from the path carved by Internet giants like Google and Facebook, which concentrated on delivering a free service to a huge number of users before turning on the revenue engine.

In those cases, of course, the money came from advertisers. You could certainly see a way for Circle to profit by advertising to its users, or selling their demographic data to marketers in some other way.

After talking with Allaire, I wouldn’t bank on that option right now. Instead, it sounds like Circle is more interested in up-selling its users on additional, premium services that could help make their digital transactions more convenient.

“We think there are a number of interesting products that we could build and offer our users that they would find useful and pay for,” Allaire said.

That doesn’t include the basic things that most financial consumers are accustomed to paying for. On its website, Circle puts it this way:

“You shouldn’t have to pay fees to use your own money. We don’t charge fees when you convert funds to or from bitcoin with a linked bank account, when you store your bitcoin, or for bitcoin transactions.”

As pointed out over at GigaOm, that’s distinct from competitors that charge a percentage fee for things like converting real-world money to bitcoins.

Circle also is not planning to make money by charging merchants for their end of a transaction with buyers. “We’re exclusively focused on consumers,” Allaire said.

Instead, Circle plans to leave the merchant-acceptance business up to companies like PayPal, Square, Stripe, and others that have begun experimenting with bitcoin as one of their digital-payment options.

“A circle user can interact with any of those, because it’s an open protocol. It’s like e-mail,” Allaire said. “We can benefit from the global investment in the merchant-acceptance side of things.”

International money transfers are an obvious possibility for Circle to make money, but the company might have to build more features if it seeks to charge premium fees. Right now, Allaire said, Circle doesn’t have a “last-mile” ability to convert international transfers back from bitcoin into the receiving person’s local currency.

So, if a Circle user in the U.S. wanted to use bitcoin to send $200 back to a relative in Brazil, their cousin on the other end of the transfer would have to take those bitcoins to a Brazilian exchange to trade them in for reals, a step that will likely cost them some money.

But, Allaire notes, the cost and time it takes to convert those bitcoins today might still beat the costs of traditional international transfers. According to figures from the World Bank, a $200 U.S.-to-Brazil transfer would typically cost 4-6 percent if you wanted it done in less than an hour.

Overall, Allaire tends to see international transfers as part of the larger digital-currency trend toward making the act of sending money a trivial technological function, just like moving media or communications over the Internet.

“It’s driving toward zero in the next two or three years, just like making a Skype call is free or sending an e-mail is free,” he said.

Since it runs an exchange where consumers can buy and sell bitcoins, Circle stands to make money on the some of the digital currency’s swings in value. But Allaire says that’s not likely a place where the company will try to make big bucks.

“Our goal in doing that is not really to generate revenue. It’s to provide that seamless customer experience—it’s more important to ensure that customers can seamlessly come in and out,” he said. “Any economic benefit that we see there really just helps to cover costs as opposed to being a source of revenue.”

One intriguing possibility for Circle’s business is tied to the possibility that bitcoin becomes a more sophisticated financial instrument, with blessing from government regulators.

Earlier this month, a New Jersey-based company called TeraExchange revealed that it had won the first approval from federal regulators for a bitcoin derivatives exchange. If a fully approved, robust derivatives market for bitcoin emerges, it could help stablilize the price of the notoriously volatile digital currency—and ensuring that $1 today will be worth $1 tomorrow is a key service if, like Allaire, you hope to get mainstream consumers to use bitcoin.

Let’s say you’re sending that $200 to the cousin in Brazil, and want to make sure it will be worth the same amount for a full day, until your relative can cash out the transfer.

“We would essentially say, `We’re buying price insurance for a rolling 24 hours of value, and it’s going to cost us 1 percent to buy that insurance,’” Allaire said. “We can pass that along as a fee, or we could eat the cost, or any of the above—and effectively, we can lock that value.”

If users are still too put off by the unclear plans for Circle’s business, Allaire and company are at least trying to make the proposition of jumping into digital currency as low-risk as possible right now. Taking another cue from the successful digital products of its era, Circle is making its initial service free and easy to try, with no attempt to lock people into a long commitment.

“The switching costs are very low,” Allaire says. “So if they feel something is at risk, they can switch their assets or their spending behavior to another piece of software, another online service, all of the above. It’s sort of like e-mail.”

Trending on Xconomy

By posting a comment, you agree to our terms and conditions.

4 responses to “Circle’s Bitcoin Service is Free—But Someone’s Gotta Pay”

  1. Corey says:

    How they make money is obvious. Every time I look, their bitcoin price is 4 dollars higher than every other exchange/wallet. They’re probably just pocketing the difference between what they pay for a coin and what they charge people for it. Ends up costing around the same amount as Coinbase even without the fees if I buy on Circle.

    • chris says:

      I have been sending my bitcoin to circle and having it deposited in my bank as USD, so they are losing on that end

    • Mike Hawk says:

      Yeah I mean thats the whole point of an exchange rate. They simply offer you less bitcoin per $USD than competitors. Which is fine, I accept that and I use circle for some things when it’s convenient. It’s the cost of doing business sometimes.

    • RostedRhino says:

      They don’t have different “buy” and “sell” prices, so if their buy price is higher than the market price as you said, they are loosing money whenever you sell your bitcoins.